NUR 752 Assignment 2.1: Critical Appraisal of Web-Based Tools
NUR 752 Assignment 2.1: Critical Appraisal of Web-Based Tools
Introduction
Your organization has set a goal to expand the use of web-based tools for their patients for your unit. As a DNP leader, you are tasked with the responsibility of selecting a web-based platform to support and improve client care within your unit at your facility. Through the lens of usability, evaluate one consumer healthcare website, consumer eHealth program aim, or electronic web-based intervention tool that you might use with your client population. Create a written proposal with your recommendation to the board.
Assignment Guidelines
Part I: Research and Identification
Step 1: Gather user experience and usability information.
- Review User Experience Honeycomb. (Links to an external site.)
- Review Usability Evaluation Basics. (Links to an external site.)
Step 2: Identify one specific web-based tool to evaluate.
Types of web-based platforms include:
- Consumer healthcare websites
- Consumer eHealth program aims
- Web-based intervention tools (Do not include e-visit or telecommunication tools as they were covered in the discussion posting.)
Part II: Written Proposal
Step 3: Evaluate one web-based platform.
- Describe the client population.
- Explain the type of web-based platform you would advise to support the care delivery.
- Evaluate one consumer healthcare website, consumer eHealth program aim, or electronic intervention tool you might use with your patient population.
- Evaluate for the balance between context, content, and user needs.
- Describe the user’s experience:
- Usefulness, Desirability, Findability, Accessibility, Credibility (and accuracy), and Value.
- Calculate the readability level. (Select a site for calculating readability; there are many such sites out there.)
- Advise on usability. Although you can’t complete the testing, you can address design, ease of learning, efficiency of use, memorability, and potential error frequency.
- Appraise how well the sites support consumers’ healthcare needs.
- Provide an overall summary of the pros and cons of the site.
Formatting and Mechanics
- Utilize APA formatting and style.
- Submit your paper as a Word document that includes the content for the proposal.
Submission
Submit your assignment and review full grading criteria on the Assignment 2.1: Critical Appraisal of Web-Based Tools page.
The unit I work for is a 32-bed adult medical-oncology unit. Though acuity has changed with covid, my unit now is the only other floor to accept tracheostomy patients. As we all know patient acuity has been increasing as patients have chronic concerns that are hard to address, though another aspect of my unit is the number of new graduate nurses. As we all know impact from staffing shortages another barrier to success in my unit is a wealth of knowledge and support due to new members.
As McBride defines it, “asynchronous telemedicine involves the exchange of prerecorded data between two or more individuals at
different times” (p. 382, 2019). Therefore, with that in mind I believe that per my patient population, this type of telemedicine would be most ideal. This is partly because as society changes with working different hours and technology becoming more advanced, patients and their providers can exchange information at different times, not needing to use video calls or be available when sharing information. Which also allows for conversation and consultations to take place virtually at any time.
As we have learned so far in this program it is how driven the market is for the consumer. Nothing works if there is no one to purchase the product, a consumer-driven market. Therefore, I believe that telemedicine is driven by the consumer. Though the concept of telemedicine is for communication between provider and patient, I believe that the patient can have most of the pull-in making changes and adding things based on their needs and wants through the application of telemedicine.
As we have read “nationally, there are 14 TRCs: 12 regional centers, all with different strengths and regional expertise, and two national centers, which focus on areas of technology assessment and telehealth policy” (McBride, p. 384, 2019). Therefore, as far as technology can reach as many people as possible who have access, legal barriers are involved when compact nursing licensure is not in all 50 states. There also must be taken into consideration ethical concerns is the fact that the patient-provider relationship becomes skewed. Patients can now search through providers through scrolling and see which fits their needs and in the off chance, they don’t like the provider they can switch at ease. Though some people do not understand technology, consideration must also be made that telemedicine/ telehealth encourages one method of thinking. Though as we all know everyone is different, their needs are different, and their qualifications are different.
Some other technologies that can be added to these visits include educational training for staff members or patients and things such as monitoring tools that link the patient’s account and readings to their HER. This is specifically beneficial to the elderly for example, to alert medical staff if there are emergency values that are recorded.
Reference
McBride, S., & Tietze, M. (2019). Nursing Informatics for the advanced practice nurse: Patient safety, quality, outcomes, and interprofessionalism (2nd ed.). Springer Publishing Company.
Week 2 Critical Appraisal of Web-Based Tools Rubric | ||
---|---|---|
Criteria | Ratings | Pts |
Introduction
|
|
5 / 5 pts
|
Background
|
|
5 / 5 pts
|
Assessment
|
|
25 / 30 pts
|
Readability
|
|
2 / 5 pts
|
Appraisal
|
|
5 / 5 pts
|
Recommendation
|
|
10 / 10 pts
|
APA style
|
|
0 / 0 pts
|
Total Points: 52 |